D.R. Horton vs Toll Brothers in Jacksonville, FL
At a glance (updated ): In the Jacksonville, FL area, D.R. Horton is selling 14 new-home communities at a median starting price of $261,195 and Toll Brothers is selling 25 at $749,000, so D.R. Horton has the lower median starting price. D.R. Horton lists more quick move-in homes (169 vs 132). Toll Brothers has more current builder incentives (29 vs 14).
D.R. Horton vs Toll Brothers, side by side
| Measure | D.R. Horton | Toll Brothers |
|---|---|---|
| Communities selling now | 14 | 25 |
| Median starting price | $261,195across 14 priced | $749,000across 20 priced |
| Price range | $199,435–$834,900 | $399,000–$2,135,000 |
| Home sizes | 1,109–3,638 sq ft | 1,607–5,659 sq ft |
| Floor plans | 136 | 120 |
| Quick move-in homes | 169 | 132 |
| Current incentives | 14 current offersSee D.R. Horton offers | 29 current offersSee Toll Brothers offers |
| Best graded deal | Grade ALimited Time Opportunity | Grade A+4.99% (5.76% APR)* FHA 30-Year Fixed |
| HOA dues | Not published | Not published |
| Top cities | Jacksonville (8), St. Augustine (2), Yulee (2) | St. Augustine (8), Jacksonville (4), Fruit Cove (3) |
Counts and prices cover communities currently selling (grand opening, selling or close-out) as published by each builder. Starting prices are base prices before options, lot premiums and incentives. Deal grades are Home Stimulus estimates.
Which to pick: where each builder leads
Neither builder is better for everyone. This is where the published numbers differ, so you can start with whichever matters most to you:
- Lower typical starting price: D.R. Horton has the lower median starting price ($261,195 vs $749,000).
- Lowest entry price: D.R. Horton has the lowest starting price in the market, from $199,435 (vs from $399,000).
- More places to choose from: Toll Brothers is selling in more communities (25 vs 14).
- Moving soon: D.R. Horton lists more quick move-in homes (169 vs 132).
- Larger homes: Toll Brothers offers larger plans, up to 5,659 sq ft (vs 3,638 sq ft).
- More current incentives: Toll Brothers has more published offers right now (29 vs 14).
- Best-graded deal: Toll Brothers's top deal grades A+ on Home Stimulus's deal scale, vs A for D.R. Horton.
D.R. Horton communities selling in Jacksonville
- Rookery · Green Cove Springs · $285,765–$409,850
- Bridle Creek · Jacksonville · $267,400–$494,900
- Bridle Creek Townhomes · Jacksonville · $199,435–$269,990
- Broward Key · Jacksonville · $439,900–$834,900
- Copes Landing · Jacksonville · $262,400–$397,850
- Hansen Creek · Jacksonville · $224,940–$285,940
- Irongate Villas · Jacksonville · $219,440–$246,990
- The Arbors · Jacksonville · $269,905–$429,350
Toll Brothers communities selling in Jacksonville
- Bartram Ranch · Fruit Cove · $799,000–$1,269,000
- Mill Creek Forest - Magnolia · Fruit Cove · $679,000–$889,000
- Mill Creek Forest - Meadows · Fruit Cove
- Shores at RiverTown - Atlantic Collection · Green Cove Springs · $455,000–$679,000
- Shores at RiverTown - Gulf Collection · Green Cove Springs · From $749,000
- Shores at RiverTown - Riverview Collection · Green Cove Springs · $589,000–$859,000
- Mariposa at EverRange · Jacksonville · $639,000–$799,000
- Regency at EverRange - Acadia Collection · Jacksonville · $629,000–$694,000
D.R. Horton vs Toll Brothers in Jacksonville: FAQ
Is D.R. Horton or Toll Brothers cheaper in Jacksonville?
D.R. Horton has a median starting price of $261,195 (lowest $199,435) across 14 priced communities in the Jacksonville area; Toll Brothers has a median starting price of $749,000 (lowest $399,000) across 20 priced communities. By median starting price, D.R. Horton is the lower-priced of the two. Starting prices are the builders' published base prices and change often; confirm with the builder.
Which builder has more new homes for sale in Jacksonville?
D.R. Horton is selling in 14 communities with 136 floor plans and 169 quick move-in homes; Toll Brothers is selling in 25 communities with 120 floor plans and 132 quick move-in homes.
What incentives are D.R. Horton and Toll Brothers offering in Jacksonville?
D.R. Horton has 14 current offers, the best graded A ("Limited Time Opportunity"). Toll Brothers has 29 current offers, the best graded A+ ("4.99% (5.76% APR)* FHA 30-Year Fixed"). Builder incentives often require the builder's affiliated lender and can end without notice; each offer on the incentives pages shows the date it was last verified.
Where do D.R. Horton and Toll Brothers build in the Jacksonville area?
D.R. Horton's selling communities are concentrated in Jacksonville, St. Augustine and Yulee; Toll Brothers's in St. Augustine, Jacksonville and Fruit Cove.
How big are D.R. Horton and Toll Brothers homes in Jacksonville?
D.R. Horton's current plans run 1,109 to 3,638 sq ft; Toll Brothers's run 1,607 to 5,659 sq ft.
Incentives can change or end without notice, vary by home and buyer eligibility, and may require financing through the builder's preferred lender. This platform does not guarantee availability. Verify all terms directly with the builder before relying on any offer.
Pricing, availability, incentives, dimensions, and completion dates are provided by the builder or other sources, are subject to change without notice, and are not guaranteed. Square footage is approximate. This page is informational only and is not an offer to sell.

